Placebos, Pharma and Government Drug Approvals

What does it mean for the FDA’s drug-approval process if, as this Economist article implies, the placebo effect is responsible for the apparent effectiveness of some of the drugs it approves?

The story triggering this thought is about sports medicine. It describes a study comparing painkilling effects of morphine with a placebo on athletes. The World Anti-Doping Agency bans the use of morphine during competition because “its painkilling properties would give users an unfair advantage.”

Killing pain, however, is one of the things that the placebo effect is best at. In 1999 Dr Benedetti himself showed that someone who is injected with morphine for two days in a row experiences a powerful analgesic response not only on those days but also on the next, if the morphine is replaced by a placebo without his knowledge. That led (University of Turin professor Dr. Fabrizio) Benedetti to wonder if the effect of legally administered pre-competition morphine might, perfectly legally, be carried over into a competition by giving a placebo.

In their new experiment, published this week in the Journal of Neuroscience, he and his colleagues simulated a sporting competition by pitting four teams of ten athletic young men against each other in a pain-endurance test. With a tourniquet strapped around one forearm, these men had to squeeze a hand-spring exerciser repeatedly until pain forced them to stop. Their scores, measured by the time they managed to keep going, were averaged over the whole team.

One of the teams received a morphine injection just before training sessions held two weeks and one week before the contest, and an injection of saline solution on the big day, along with the suggestion that it was morphine. Another received the same regime, but the saline was combined with naloxone, an opiate-blocking drug. The remaining teams received either no treatment at all, or the placebo on competition day alone.

Members of the team that received morphine followed by a placebo were able to endure significantly more pain during the competition than any of their rivals. In particular, those injected with naloxone did no better than the other two control groups. This finding supports the theory that placebos reduce pain by encouraging the brain to produce more natural opiates than usual.

The Economist thinks aloud about the implications. What if a doctor told an athlete he was being administered an illegal painkiller, and the athlete believed it. The placebo effect kicks in. Is that athlete cheating?

But the bigger picture is the power of the placebo effect. How much mainstream, FDA-approved medication was approved based on placebo-effect-fueled results from human tests? How many approved drugs are effective because of a feedback loop reinforced by doctors’ assurances, advertising and word-of-mouth? Is “the placebo effect” merely a pejorative term for the body’s ability to heal itself? Is healing-by-placebo any less valid than healing-by-drugs?  Do drugs interfere with self-healing/placebo effect, or are they enhanced by it?

Obviously, pharma companies need to have some level of testing and approval, if only to assure that their drugs don’t poison people. But when a drug seems to be effective but the placebo effect is suspected, the FDA considers that drug to have failed. Is that really the right way to look at it?

Taking it further, should the FDA be working with health practitioners on ways the government can help drug manufacturers create the basis of belief that would support the placebo benefits? And shouldn’t the government find a way to support homeopathic and other alternative medications, rather than — as they do now — trying to ruin users’ faith in them?

Placebo might be just another word for healing, in some instances. What are the implications of that?

Explore posts in the same categories: Health Care, Pharma, Sports

Tags: , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: